Skip to main content

Search hotels in Shelter Island, NY

Enter your dates to see the latest prices and deals for Shelter Island hotels

Shelter Island – 3 hotels and places to stay

Show hotels on map

Filter by:

Star rating

Review score

The Pridwin Hotel

Hotel in Shelter Island

The Pridwin is a waterfront resort located on Shelter Island with 33 well-appointed guest rooms and 16 private cottages an all-American restaurant and lively lounge with water views a full service...

M
Morgan
From
United States
The staff was incredibly friendly, helpful and attentive. They were especially accomodating to our children.
Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.3
Superb - What previous guests thought, 95 reviews
Price from
£360.30
1 night, 2 adults
Check availability

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

Greenport (Near Shelter Island)

Set in Greenport, 41 km from Splish Splash, Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows offers accommodation with free bikes, free private parking, a garden and a private beach area.

F
Franz
From
Austria
It‘s a very nice place with Great attention to Details. Everyone who worked there, in the Hotel, the bar and in the Diner, were very friendly, helpful and accommodating. It felt like you had been a guest many times before
Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.6
Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 101 reviews
Price from
£334.03
1 night, 2 adults
Check availability

The Menhaden Hotel

Greenport (Near Shelter Island)

Boasting a terrace, bar and views of city, The Menhaden Hotel is situated in Greenport, 41 km from Splish Splash.

S
Svitlana
From
Ukraine
From the self service breakfast and tea time in the evenings, the kitchenette was amazing. The rooms are spacious, lovely interior and exterior. The rooftop lounge and bar is just that cherry on top. They have a cafe and small shop with all your holiday essentials within the hotel which is incredibly convenient. The staff was incredible as well, would like to especially point out Mario (the manager), Dan (the bartender), Aedan (the receptionist), and Alfred (the room service expert).
Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.3
Superb - What previous guests thought, 112 reviews
Price from
£257.08
1 night, 2 adults
Check availability

Hotel Moraine

Greenport (Near Shelter Island)

Located in Greenport, 39 km from Splish Splash, Hotel Moraine provides accommodation with free bikes, free private parking, a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness centre.

C
Clement
From
France
The VIEW The warm swimming pool The quiet private beach and its pebbles The fitness centre
Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.5
Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 59 reviews
Price from
£481.07
1 night, 2 adults
Check availability

American Beech Hotel

Greenport (Near Shelter Island)

American Beech Hotel has free bikes, garden, a restaurant and bar in Greenport. This 4-star hotel offers free WiFi. The property is allergy-free and is situated 42 km from Splish Splash.

L
Laura
From
Germany
Beautiful hotel located in a very nice area of Greenport surrounded by bars, restaurants and little shops. Our room was super clean and we liked the style very much. Parking was easy! We parked the car just next to the hotel in a street where a ticket was not even required. The staff is super friendly and the breakfast basket was a really nice touch! We enjoyed our stay to the fullest :)
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.9
Fabulous - What previous guests thought, 142 reviews
Price from
£227.80
1 night, 2 adults
Check availability

Sound View Greenport

Greenport (Near Shelter Island)

Set on the North Fork in Greenport, 157 km from New York City, Sound View Greenport features a seasonal outdoor pool and views of the Long Island Sound. Guests can enjoy a drink at the bar.

R
Romain
From
France
This outstanding hotel, frozen in time, along with its amazing location, deserves an exceptionally better staff. The staff were untrained and lacking experience, appearing overly casual. They seemed to be more like students than professionals. They advertised a "valet parking" service, but even if the attendant by the hotel entrance was charming, this "service" was nothing short of a joke. There was a lack of information and a general sense of indifference. The reception had an amateurish feel, with an 18-year-old girl visibly struggling to operate the computer. Regardless, this place is an absolute dream..
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.1
Very good - What previous guests thought, 223 reviews
Price from
£191.14
1 night, 2 adults
Check availability

Baron's Cove

Sag Harbor (Near Shelter Island)

Featuring an on-site restaurant and seasonal saltwater swimming pool, Baron's Cove is situated in Sag Harbor, New York.

L
Laura
From
United Kingdom
The hotel was beautiful and clean. Love the views. The bed! The staff were really nice and welcoming. Special shout out to Mohamed and Maria. I was new to the area- when it was time to get back to the city I had some trouble getting a car to take me to the station. Mohamed and Maria went above and beyond to help me. I didn't have cash on me so I was actually driven to a bank and then the station. Generally kind and good people. Thank you so much.
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.9
Fabulous - What previous guests thought, 152 reviews
Price from
£554.80
1 night, 2 adults
Check availability

The Harbor Front Inn

Greenport (Near Shelter Island)

Offering a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness center, The Harbor Front Inn is centrally located near the shops and restaurants in Greenport. Free WiFi access is available.

R
Robert
From
United Kingdom
Very clean. Spacious rooms - ours had a lovely view. Staff friendly, professional and super helpful.
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.3
Very good - What previous guests thought, 242 reviews
Price from
£191.14
1 night, 2 adults
Check availability

Sag Harbor Inn

Sag Harbor (Near Shelter Island)

Set in Sag Harbor, within 25 km of Montauk Point Lighthouse and 34 km of Second House Museum, Sag Harbor Inn offers accommodation with a shared lounge and as well as free private parking for guests...

F
Fiona Ann
From
United Kingdom
Loved the warm feeling as soon as you walk through the door in a cold and rainy afternoon. John on reception went oit of his way to make us feel at home. Thanks for the delicious local wine!
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.7
Fabulous - What previous guests thought, 97 reviews
Price from
£291.54
1 night, 2 adults
Check availability

The Shoals Suites & Slips

Southold (Near Shelter Island)

Set in Southold, 37 km from Splish Splash, The Shoals Suites & Slips offers accommodation with a garden, free private parking, a terrace and a bar.

L
Louise
From
France
Lovely place, in a small marina. The apartment was beautiful, confy and well equipped. Good breakfast with an amazing sea view.
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.9
Fabulous - What previous guests thought, 61 reviews
Price from
£406.65
1 night, 2 adults
Check availability
See all hotels in and around Shelter Island

Most booked hotels in Shelter Island and surroundings in the past month

See all

  • Popular with guests booking hotels in Shelter Island

    Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.3
    Superb - What previous guests thought, 95 reviews

  • Popular with guests booking hotels in Greenport

    Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.3
    Very good - What previous guests thought, 242 reviews

  • Popular with guests booking hotels in Greenport

    Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.1
    Very good - What previous guests thought, 223 reviews

  • Popular with guests booking hotels in Greenport

    Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.9
    Fabulous - What previous guests thought, 142 reviews

  • Popular with guests booking hotels in Greenport

    Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.3
    Superb - What previous guests thought, 112 reviews

  • Popular with guests booking hotels in Sag Harbor

    Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.9
    Fabulous - What previous guests thought, 152 reviews

  • Popular with guests booking hotels in Sag Harbor

    Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.7
    Fabulous - What previous guests thought, 97 reviews

  • Popular with guests booking hotels in Greenport

    Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.6
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 101 reviews

  • Popular with guests booking hotels in Greenport

    Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.7
    Fabulous - What previous guests thought, 130 reviews

  • Popular with guests booking hotels in Southold

    Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.9
    Fabulous - What previous guests thought, 61 reviews

Best hotels with breakfast in Shelter Island and nearby

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.8
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 65 reviews

    Just 450 metres to the beach, this bed and breakfast is located in Shelter Island Heights. A free breakfast is served each morning.

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.3
    Very good - What previous guests thought, 242 reviews

    Offering a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness center, The Harbor Front Inn is centrally located near the shops and restaurants in Greenport. Free WiFi access is available.

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.9
    Fabulous - What previous guests thought, 142 reviews

    American Beech Hotel has free bikes, garden, a restaurant and bar in Greenport. This 4-star hotel offers free WiFi. The property is allergy-free and is situated 42 km from Splish Splash.

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.1
    Very good - What previous guests thought, 223 reviews

    Set on the North Fork in Greenport, 157 km from New York City, Sound View Greenport features a seasonal outdoor pool and views of the Long Island Sound. Guests can enjoy a drink at the bar.

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.7
    Fabulous - What previous guests thought, 97 reviews

    Set in Sag Harbor, within 25 km of Montauk Point Lighthouse and 34 km of Second House Museum, Sag Harbor Inn offers accommodation with a shared lounge and as well as free private parking for guests...

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 7.9
    Good - What previous guests thought, 21 reviews

    Situated in Shelter Island Heights, West Neck Guesthouse features free bikes and garden. This guest house features free private parking and a housekeeping service. The guest house has family rooms.

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.8
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 19 reviews

    Featuring pool views, Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast provides accommodation with a private beach area, a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a garden, around 42 km from Splish Splash.

  • Featuring air-conditioned accommodation with a patio, Modern on 9th is located in Greenport. The holiday home is 41 km from Splish Splash. The property has a restaurant with an outdoor dining area.

Budget hotels in Shelter Island and nearby

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.8
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 21 reviews

    Featuring a garden and views of garden, The Stirling House Waterfront Inn Greenport is a bed and breakfast situated in a historic building in Greenport, 42 km from Splish Splash.

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.8
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 15 reviews

    Located in Greenport in the New York region, Bright Apartment - half Mi to Greenport Harbor! has a patio. Providing free WiFi throughout the property, the non-smoking apartment features a spa centre.

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 10.0
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 2 reviews

    Situated in Greenport in the New York region, Quaint DT Greenport Apt - 2 Mi to Shelter Island! features a patio.

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.0
    Superb - What previous guests thought, 1 review

    Featuring a sauna, Cozy Greenport Cottage is set in Greenport. Guests can benefit from a patio and an outdoor fireplace. The property is non-smoking and is located 41 km from Splish Splash.

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 10.0
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 2 reviews

    Situated in Greenport, within 27 km of Long Island Railroad, Charming Greenport Gem 1, 1 Mile to Ferry! offers accommodation with air conditioning.

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.0
    Very good - What previous guests thought, 3 reviews

    Set in Greenport, within 40 km of Splish Splash and 25 km of Long Island Railroad, North Fork Cottages & RV Resort offers accommodation with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool as well as free private...

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.2
    Superb - What previous guests thought, 24 reviews

    A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast has garden views, free WiFi and free private parking, set in Southold, 1.9 km from Cedar Beach County Park.

  • Set in Greenport in the New York region, Beachfront Greenport Villa offers accommodation with free WiFi and free private parking. This holiday home is 23 km from Long Island Railroad.

See reviews by guests who stayed at hotels in Shelter Island

See all

  • The Pridwin Hotel

    Shelter Island
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.3
    Superb - What previous guests thought, 95 reviews
    I loved this hotel. Beautiful decorated old school hotel feeling. Beautiful setting right across from lake. Pool and pool service were wonderful. Room was exceedingly comfortable. Staff were very efficient and lovely. Live music in restaurant one of the nights.
    Guest review by
    Margaret
    United States

  • Rams Head Inn

    Shelter Island
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.1
    Very good - What previous guests thought, 35 reviews
    It is a very charming hotel in a beautiful natural landscape with dears rabbits squirrels. The beach was cozy and the stuff was extremely nice and friendship. It was the best relaxing few days to close our New York visit. I will never forget this holiday.
    Guest review by
    Timea
    Hungary

  • Rams Head Inn

    Shelter Island
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.1
    Very good - What previous guests thought, 35 reviews
    The staff was nice and accommodating; the building was beautiful; and it was the best calm getaway I’ve had in a while. The hotel also offers kayaks and SUP for free…as well as food for the sheep that are on site.
    Guest review by
    gina
    United States

  • Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach

    Shelter Island Heights
    From £230.03 per night
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.8
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 65 reviews
    We had an amazing stay at Seven. Beth and Patrick are very accommodating and friendly. Seven has everything you need for a great stay at Shelter Island. We really liked the pool, gym area and breakfast.
    Guest review by
    Marjan
    Netherlands

  • Rams Head Inn

    Shelter Island
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.1
    Very good - What previous guests thought, 35 reviews
    Quiet, beautiful, great food, wonderful staff. We even got to meet the owner and hear more about her vision for the hotel - one which we strongly support.
    Guest review by
    Michael
    United States

Research, refine and make plans for your whole trip

Hotels near Mohegan Sun Casino

Search and compare hotels close to Mohegan Sun Casino, a popular destination just outside Shelter Island.

Hotels near Mystic Seaport

Hotels close to a popular local landmark.

Hotels in the United States

Pack a bigger bag and see more of the country.

Hotels in Long Island

Extend your search and explore the surrounding area.

Hotels in New York State

Extend your search and explore the surrounding area.

Hotels in Montauk

Find more hotels in a city close to Montauk.

Hotels in Groton

Flexible on where to stay? Look up hotels in nearby Groton, not too far from Shelter Island.

When to visit the United States

Events, prices, the weather and more.

Hotels in Greenport

Try another destination popular with our guests.

Hotels in New Woodstock

Try another destination popular with our guests.

Hotels near Tweed-New Haven Airport

Perfect for a late arrival or early departure.

Hotels near Long Island MacArthur Airport

Perfect for a late arrival or early departure.

Hotels with Parking in Shelter Island

Explore more great accommodation options in Shelter Island, starting with hotels with parking.

Villas in Shelter Island

More great accommodation options for your trip.

Holiday Homes in Shelter Island

More great accommodation options for your trip.

Cottages in Shelter Island

More great accommodation options for your trip.

Pet-Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island

More great accommodation options for your trip.

Hotels in New York

Discover another destination in the United States.

Hotels in Las Vegas

Take a look at hotels in Las Vegas and explore more of the United States.