Reviews of Caye Caulker Beach Hotel 4 stars

Reasonable value at around 60$/night. Perhaps even better value if there's two of you, but then the room (and bed) would perhaps be a bit on the small side. Note that there is a window in the bathroom, so you are not completely in the dark. This was an unexpected plus. Location very convenient and staff very pleasant. Very practical to have the little supermarket downstairs. Shower was large and worked very well.

As noted by others, there is a strong odour in the bathroom that some might be bothered by. The floor was also not very clean, but I understand that given that the town has no paved roads so there is sand everywhere.

Beautiful location with lovely area on roof with shade, hammocks, and spectacular view of the water and Main Street.

No elevator, and I was on the 4th (top) floor. The worst was the odor from the toilet area. It smelled like sewer gas was coming in. From looking at reviews, this has been going on for a long time. At least there was a door that could be kept shut between the bedroom and rest room.

We arrived without any booking beforehand on the island (dumb) and this was the cheapest option left. It's a simple, clean hotel with a nice bed and shower. Not a place to hang out during the day, just to sleep.

There was a leak in another guest's room which flooded the hallway and our room too, including our bags and clothes, etc. The staff was very apologetic and helped us clean it up, but nothing more. Ofcourse the leak was outside of their hands but I think it would've been nice if they offered us to move rooms since everything was wet and smelly and we still had to sleep there a few days.

It was one of the more budget options on the island and is well located. Check in is via the supermarket beneath, so no hotel reception or amenities etc. The cleaning staff were friendly and the rooms were clean generally but basic.

The bathroom had a foul smell at all times

Wasn’t very clean

Nice rooftop terrace with kitchen, clean small room, one of the cheapest options, still a little pricy

Rooftop terrace is quite dirt pigeons everywhere

Amazing location, very clean and great staff. Awesome A/C and shower. We didn’t expect much based on other reviews but we were very pleasantly surprised.

Good location. Spacious room comfy bed and bathroom, with a great shower. Nice view from the window

The 50 stairs to the 4th floor!

The location was great and it was very clean. Staff were helpful and friendly. The accommodations are expensive in San Pedro as this one, but at least it ticked the boxes for me.

Overlooks the ocean

No otherrestaurants or bars close by

We knew we had booked a budget friendly hotel so we weren’t expecting much - we chose it for its location which was wonderful , and ended up loving the shower !!! (Better than my shower at home ) and the bed was extremely comfy !!

Bathroom had a strong sewage smell - we covered the drain with a garbage can and kept the door closed and that helped but it’s good to note - there’s also a shared kitchen area upstairs which was awesome but we ended up not usuing it as there was a lot of pigeon poop surrounding the area and it felt like not a great place to cook food - we also didn’t mind the stairs but it’s good to note we had a solid set up stairs to get up to floor 4 !

A/C in the room was great and it's probably the cheapest AC private room on the island so there's that. The shower was the best thing in the rooms great pressure and nice hot water. Roof top terrace is nice with hammocks, but it's a pigeon fest and full of poo.

Kitchen is totally unusable, only one rusty dirty pan and one tiny wonky frying pan. We brought our own food and had expected to cook here, but it's not a usable kitchen. We stayed 5 nights in total and asked staff on first morning if they could provide new pans. But none turned up. There's also a pigeon nesting in the kitchen on the shelf!! Room was also tiny much smaller than it looked on photos, with nowhere to put bags. For 5 nights we were quite cramped.

It was matchbox cool for someone who wanted to spend the days on the beach and sleep and wash at night 50 steps up to get to the top though that’s the only down staff was excellent everything

The proximity to the beach and other restaurants and properties that I wanted to visit