The 4 Best Hotels in Eleuthera Island

Based on 503 guest reviews

Coral Sands Inn & Cottages

#2 of 11 Hotels in Eleuthera Island

Last review posted: 49 days ago

“”
“Charming option on Pink Sand Beach”
“Beaches, pickleball court and cold plunge”

Ranked 2 out of 11 in the region, as well as being 2 of for hotels in Harbour Island.

Mika's Resort

#3 of 11 Hotels in Eleuthera Island

Last review posted: 37 days ago

“Very relaxing”
“Amazing value, amazing location, perfect in all ways minus the lack of black out curtains.”
“Not worth the trip..”

Ranked 3 out of 11 in the region, as well as being 3 of for hotels in Colebrooke Dale.

Valentines Resort & Marina

#4 of 11 Hotels in Eleuthera Island

Last review posted: 26 days ago

“”
“”
“”

Ranked 4 out of 11 in the region, as well as being 4 of for hotels in Harbour Island.

The Sugar Apple Lodging

#5 of 11 Hotels in Eleuthera Island

Last review posted: 498 days ago

“Great location, friendly and helpful staff”
“Lovely clean place that’s spacious with nice towels and linens also great location and Rosita is there for all your need”
“Main reason is the host whose name is Miss Rosie.”

Ranked 5 out of 11 in the region, as well as being 5 of for hotels in Harbour Island.

Guests' Choice shows you the best and most reviewed properties on top. This is based on the most important topics to our guests, like the number of recent reviews, the review score and the expertise of the reviewer.

Recent reviews

The Sunset Cove and Rainbow Room Review score: 8

“Location and service was great!”
Eleven Bahama House Review score: 10

“The property is amazing (it’s honestly the best hotel I’ve seen on the island). It is not right on Pink Sands Beach - which is anyway less than a 5’ walk away - but that can be a bonus if, like us, you don’t want to be right in the middle of the beach hustle and bustle. Not all the rooms have sea view; you might want to be discerning at the moment of booking; all of them though ensure privacy thanks to the double gazing windows and face the lush communal spaces which are pink dotted with a delightful colonial style. The staff is superlative - we had an issue caused by booking through a third party provider, but the local manager handled it gracefully. All of the people on the property were really caring and warm, from the receptionist, to the pool attendants; a special thanks goes to the bartender. The food by BH restaurant is simply delicious and I can’t recommend enough trying the experience.”
The Sunset Cove and Rainbow Room Review score: 8

“The staff was amazing. Stephanie was truly a gracious and extremely helpful host. Went over and beyond to make our stay enjoyable. Highly recommended”
Unique Village Review score: 1

“The beach”
Mika's Resort Review score: 3

“The view and sunrise from the casita are beautiful.”
Bay Inn Estates Review score: 10

“Cleanliness and location”
The Cove Eleuthera Review score: 3

“Location”
Sugar Cakes Tiny House Review score: 8

“Good Customer Service”
Unique Village Review score: 10

“The location, the spacious room and the view!”
Unique Village Review score: 5

“The view was spectacular. Just make sure you get the second floor deluxe unit rather than Superior which is on the ground floor and below pool level. No view at all. I can't understand why they would make a hotel that didn't have all view rooms.”

There are even more property options for you

B&Bs and inns in Eleuthera Island Holiday rentals in Eleuthera Island