The 4 Best Hotels in Great Barrier Island

Based on 119 guest reviews

Aotea Lodge Escape Packages

#1 of 4 Hotels in Great Barrier Island

Last review posted: 120 days ago

“Felt all the stress of city living and a busy life just melt away the minute we stepped onto the isl”
“Great place to relax”
“really quiet and cosy”

Ranked 1 out of 4 in the region, as well as being 1 of for hotels in Tryphena.

Glenfern Sanctuary

#2 of 4 Hotels in Great Barrier Island

Last review posted: 183 days ago

“Nice, renovated cottage in pleasant garden”
“I loved the quiet space and very helpful staff when we had...”
“Fabulous views and wildlife but needs a spring clean”

Ranked 2 out of 4 in the region, as well as being 2 of for hotels in Port Fitzroy.

Tipi and Bobs Waterfront Lodge

#3 of 4 Hotels in Great Barrier Island

Last review posted: 136 days ago

“Enjoyable great bed and shower pressure.”
“would love to return someday”
“Staff were very helpful and quickly resolved the remote that...”

Ranked 3 out of 4 in the region, as well as being 3 of for hotels in Tryphena.

Karaka Bay Lodge

#4 of 4 Hotels in Great Barrier Island

Last review posted: 87 days ago

“We can chill out in calm atomosphere!”
“Will be back again and again”
“We loved it. It was so peaceful, yet there was so much to do.”

Ranked 4 out of 4 in the region, as well as being 4 of for hotels in Great Barrier Island.

Guests' Choice shows you the best and most reviewed properties on top. This is based on the most important topics to our guests, like the number of recent reviews, the review score and the expertise of the reviewer.

Recent reviews

Karaka Bay Lodge Review score: 8

“Awesome location.”
Awesome View Cottage Review score: 9

“Great location and view nestled amongst native bush”
Fantasy Island - private seaview cabins Review score: 9

“We spent a wonderful weekend at Fantasy Island. The room we had was perfect with a lovely outlook to the gorgeous tropical gardens and see beyond. The host was very welcoming, friendly informative and gracious. I would highly recommend for those looking for lovely good value-for-money accommodation near Tryphena.”
Aotea Lodge Escape Packages Review score: 10

“Beautiful gardens. Accom was super clean. Location was fabulous. And the owners were amazing.”
Fantasy Island - private seaview cabins Review score: 10

“Beautiful gardens, views and surroundings. Gorgeous, clean, tidy cabins with everything you need. Friendly and accommodating host. Fantastic stay.”
Tipi and Bobs Waterfront Lodge Review score: 8

“Dining room not operating”
Fantasy Island - private seaview cabins Review score: 6

“Good location, beautiful gardens and our host was great, very welcoming, showed us around the property and gave us some local tips. We had a lot of rain during our visit and the DVDs in the cabin kept us entertained.”
Glenfern Sanctuary Review score: 10

“everything”
Aotea Lodge Escape Packages Review score: 8

“Great location, easy walk to the store, beach and local pub, which was great for meals.”

There are even more property options for you

B&Bs and inns in Great Barrier Island Holiday rentals in Great Barrier Island