Ranked 31 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 3 for hotels in Sag Harbor.

• “Sag Harbour Top!”
• “Location”
• “A low key relaxing stay with great food and drinks”
• See more reviews of Baron's Cove

Ranked 32 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 2 for hotels in Bridgehampton.

• “Wouldn't change a thing about this well managed, well kept, gracious country inn with excellent food”
• “Excellent”
• “Nice and convenient location, great parking…very charming”
• See more reviews of Bridgehampton Inn

Ranked 33 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 2 for hotels in Holtsville.

• “”
• “Everything except my girl thought we were at the Beach”
• “Everyone was awesome and very helpful.”
• See more reviews of Holiday Inn - Long Island - ISLIP Arpt East by IHG

Ranked 34 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 11 of 30 for hotels in Montauk.

• “Perfect stay”
• “”
• “Luxury”
• See more reviews of Montauk Yacht Club

Ranked 35 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 1 for hotels in Aquebogue.

• “Not worth the money for the stay.”
• “It was a relaxing couple of days! Very peaceful and the staff was amazing! Would love to come back”
• “We had an amazing trip! My dog ​​loved it! Beautiful place😍”
• See more reviews of Aqua by American Beech - Adults Only

Ranked 36 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 2 of 3 for hotels in Sag Harbor.

• “Wonderful and relaxing .”
• “”
• “Basic minimum supplied. Old towels. Very expensive for what we received.”
• See more reviews of Sag Harbor Inn

Ranked 37 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 2 for hotels in Central Islip.

• “Manger should give complete details about your payment.”
• “Great location, very convenient to family.”
• “Good, comfortable place to stay.”
• See more reviews of Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

Ranked 38 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 3 of 8 for hotels in Riverhead.

• “Great atmosphere!”
• “Breakfast was uninspiring.”
• “I thought this hotel was extremely overpriced $600 for one night one room”
• See more reviews of Hotel Indigo East End by IHG

Ranked 39 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 2 of 5 for hotels in Garden City.

• “A classic hotel in a great location. I recommend for those staying ion Long Island”
• “”
• “Great location.”
• See more reviews of Garden City Hotel

Ranked 40 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 3 of 5 for hotels in Amagansett.

• “Wonderful location.”
• “Comfortable, private and relaxing stay.”
• “The managers were exceptionally nice and welcoming.”
• See more reviews of Ocean Vista Resort

Ranked 41 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 3 for hotels in Rockville Centre.

• “surprisingly beautiful”
• “”
• “”
• See more reviews of Hampton Inn & Suites By Hilton - Rockville Centre

Ranked 42 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 5 for hotels in Ronkonkoma.

• “”
• “”
• “”
• See more reviews of Homewood Suites By Hilton Ronkonkoma

Ranked 43 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 2 of 3 for hotels in Southold.

• “Good value, clean, helpful staff and the beach was across the street. Beautiful sunset!”
• “Loved it! Super clean room, right across from beach. Staff was very friendly. Not one complaint!”
• “Everything was great! Would stay again!”
• See more reviews of Southold Beach Motel

Ranked 44 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 3 for hotels in Farmingdale.

• “”
• “”
• “”
• See more reviews of Courtyard Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale

Ranked 45 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 12 of 30 for hotels in Montauk.

• “”
• “”
• “”
• See more reviews of Marram

Ranked 46 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 4 of 8 for hotels in Riverhead.

• “Very happy!”
• “”
• “Poor”
• See more reviews of Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites East End by IHG

Ranked 47 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 4 for hotels in Plainview.

• “Great place and friendly staff. I will come back again.”
• “Beds and pillows were comfortable.”
• “Very comfortable stay”
• See more reviews of Hilton Garden Inn Melville

Ranked 48 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 8 of 11 for hotels in Greenport.

• “Good location, clean rooms, nice staff, but if you are looking to rest on a Fri, Sat or Sun night during the summer go e”
• “”
• “”
• See more reviews of American Beech Hotel

Ranked 49 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 3 for hotels in Huntington.

• “”
• “”
• “”
• See more reviews of Whitman Motor Lodge

Ranked 50 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 2 of 3 for hotels in Huntington.

• “Amazing place at all levels”
• “We had a bad experience.”
• “”
• See more reviews of Hampton Inn & Suites Huntington Downtown, Ny

Ranked 51 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 2 for hotels in Stony Brook.

• “”
• “”
• “”
• See more reviews of Hilton Garden Inn Stony Brook

Ranked 52 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 5 of 8 for hotels in Riverhead.

• “”
• “It was a short overnight stay. I didn't get the full experience as we left early morning”
• “”
• See more reviews of Residence Inn by Marriott New York Long Island East End

Ranked 53 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 2 of 4 for hotels in Plainview.

• “”
• “”
• “Stayed there with my family and pets, in NY for a celebration”
• See more reviews of Homewood Suites by Hilton Long Island-Melville

Ranked 54 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 2 of 5 for hotels in Ronkonkoma.

• “Nice clean staff was very helpful”
• “Very good location,nice friendly staff and good size rooms”
• “”
• See more reviews of Courtyard Long Island MacArthur Airport

Ranked 55 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 4 of 5 for hotels in Amagansett.

• “”
• “”
• “Location, Nice room, clean”
• See more reviews of Windward Shores

Ranked 56 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 3 for hotels in Carle Place.

• “Location and room”
• “”
• “Fabulous. Would go again.”
• See more reviews of SpringHill Suites by Marriott Carle Place Garden City

Ranked 57 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 2 for hotels in Commack.

• “”
• “I will return for the location but teach manners”
• “”
• See more reviews of Hampton Inn Long Island/Commack

Ranked 58 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of 1 for hotels in Centereach.

• “”
• “Room and hotel was very clean”
• “Very pleased with everything.”
• See more reviews of Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook-Long Island by IHG

Ranked 59 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 3 of 5 for hotels in Garden City.

• “Good stay and comfortable”
• “”
• “Great stay!”
• See more reviews of Hyatt Place Garden City

Ranked 60 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 2 of 2 for hotels in Central Islip.

• “”
• “They made me feel like it was worth staying there and I shouldn't even consider other options.”
• “Breakfast and front desk agent excellent”
• See more reviews of Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex