The 30 Best Hotels in Long Island

Based on 46,893 guest reviews

Fathoms Hotel & Marina

#1 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 8 days ago

“Enjoyable , perfect”
“Everything was fantastic.”
“Cindie and Steve are remarkable hosts who create a relaxed,...”

Ranked 1 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 1 of for hotels in Port Washington.

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

#2 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 2 days ago

“”
“”
“”

Ranked 2 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 2 of for hotels in Greenport.

Hotel Moraine

#3 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 21 days ago

“”
“Relaxing getaway”
“Came here for a getaway with my girlfriend. The hotel was perfect and am planning on coming back.”

Ranked 3 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 3 of for hotels in Greenport.

Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort

#4 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 4 days ago

“Between the pool and the beach, we had a very fun and relaxing vacation. Highly recommend it!”
“We had a great time.”
“”

Ranked 4 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 4 of for hotels in Montauk.

The Menhaden Hotel

#5 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 24 days ago

“”
“We were very warmly welcomed and attended to.”
“”

Ranked 5 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 5 of for hotels in Greenport.

The Roundtree, Amagansett

#6 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 12 days ago

“Excellent time!”
“Great place, very friendly and accommodating staff, bonfires...”
“Beautiful, well-kept, and felt like a home away from home”

Ranked 6 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 6 of for hotels in Amagansett.

Aqualina Inn Montauk

#7 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 9 days ago

“”
“Location is fabulous”
“My long awaited return to Montauk was lovely thanks to Aqualina Inn”

Ranked 7 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 7 of for hotels in Montauk.

Residence Inn Long Island Garden City

#8 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 18 days ago

“Everything”
“”
“Very nice!”

Ranked 8 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 8 of for hotels in Garden City.

The Quogue Club

#9 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 2 days ago

“”
“Good but the toast for one breakfast was black / burnt”
“Wonderful hotel!”

Ranked 9 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 9 of for hotels in Quogue.

Colonial Shores Resort

#10 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 9 days ago

“”
“Everything as described was true”
“Nice solution”

Ranked 10 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 10 of for hotels in Hampton Bays.

The Preston House and Hotel

#11 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 21 days ago

“Great hotel in Riverhead”
“”
“”

Ranked 11 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 11 of for hotels in Riverhead.

Daunts Albatross Motel

#12 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 2 days ago

“”
“I absolutely love this property—everything is just so easy.”
“Loved the courtyard, the pool area, and the location.”

Ranked 12 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 12 of for hotels in Montauk.

Sea Crest

#13 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 2 days ago

“”
“”
“”

Ranked 13 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 13 of for hotels in Amagansett.

The Pridwin Hotel

#14 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 4 days ago

“”
“Great”
“Great place lacking trained staff”

Ranked 14 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 14 of for hotels in Shelter Island.

The Hermitage at Napeague

#15 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 8 days ago

“A great place to go.”
“”
“Comfortable stay at this nice, well situated property.”

Ranked 15 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 15 of for hotels in Amagansett.

The Bentley Hotel Southampton

#16 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 4 days ago

“Plenty of better options with professional staff in the area.”
“Room was great”
“A beautiful find, if we ever return to the hamptons we will be back!”

Ranked 16 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 16 of for hotels in Southampton.

Sun and Sound Montauk

#17 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 2 days ago

“Perfect location with beautiful views.”
“Location it’s just perfect”
“Love the sun and sound. We have had our family vacations here the last 3 years and we love e”

Ranked 17 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 17 of for hotels in Montauk.

Montauk Manor

#18 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 2 days ago

“It felt very secluded and peaceful. Breathtaking views.”
“On the whole my stay was extremely nice”
“The property is beautiful, convenient free shuttle”

Ranked 18 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 18 of for hotels in Montauk.

The Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel

#19 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 7 days ago

“Amazing as always”
“”
“”

Ranked 19 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 19 of for hotels in Woodbury.

The Ocean Resort Inn

#20 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 3 days ago

“”
“”
“”

Ranked 20 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 20 of for hotels in Montauk.

Driftwood Resort on the Ocean

#21 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 6 days ago

“Great location”
“My favorite”
“Updated, clean resort on a pristine beach actually worth the resort fee.”

Ranked 21 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 21 of for hotels in Montauk.

Beach Plum Resort

#22 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 5 days ago

“Beautiful property, great location”
“”
“overall it was good. I wish it was more comfortable”

Ranked 22 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 22 of for hotels in Montauk.

Ocean View Terrace

#23 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 3 days ago

“Location, location, location!”
“Too noisy due to à Road nearby in spire of my request to get...”
“”

Ranked 23 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 23 of for hotels in Hampton Bays.

White Sands Motel

#24 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 6 days ago

“We only slept there, never and won’t recommend !”
“”
“Ocean front, peaceful”

Ranked 24 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 24 of for hotels in Amagansett.

Montauk Blue Hotel

#25 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 2 days ago

“It was so nice and clean and directly on the beach”
“”
“”

Ranked 25 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 25 of for hotels in Montauk.

Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven

#26 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 2 days ago

“”
“It was a great location for our family trip.”
“”

Ranked 26 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 26 of for hotels in Yaphank.

Hilton Garden Inn Roslyn

#27 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 2 days ago

“”
“”
“”

Ranked 27 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 27 of for hotels in Roslyn.

East Hampton House Resort

#28 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 5 days ago

“Very clean and comfortable”
“A beautiful property, clean and comfortable but very expensive.”
“Absolutely would stay again, maybe top floor next time. Rooms clean, great location, beautiful maintained property”

Ranked 28 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 28 of for hotels in East Hampton.

Beachcomber Resort at Montauk

#29 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 2 days ago

“”
“”
“”

Ranked 29 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 29 of for hotels in Montauk.

Hyatt Place Long Island East End

#30 of 161 Hotels in Long Island

Last review posted: 9 days ago

“Location”
“”
“”

Ranked 30 out of 161 in the region, as well as being 30 of for hotels in Riverhead.

Guests' Choice shows you the best and most reviewed properties on top. This is based on the most important topics to our guests, like the number of recent reviews, the review score and the expertise of the reviewer.

Recent reviews

Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia Review score: 9

“There is a lot of parking. The breakfast has lots of variation, and you can get coffee to go. The staff was really nice and helpful. The beds are comfortable, and the wifi is really good! The bathroom was very roomy.”
Hilton Garden Inn Westbury Review score: 3

“The location”
The Atlantic Review score: 10

“The staff is super friendly and efficient”
Hampton Inn & Suites By Hilton - Rockville Centre Review score: 8

“Large room, very clean, comfortable bed and friendly staff. Also close to the train station and easy access into NYC. We were staying at the hotel as we were going to the Outlaw Festival at Jones Beach theater.”
Allegria Hotel Review score: 8

“location”
East Norwich Inn Review score: 9

“No breakfast but now the biggest change is the frontdesk staff which was previously extremely rude . Now the new staff is extremely polite n helpful.”
Shorewood Inn Review score: 9

“Everything was perfect. Coffee was great.”
Best Western Mill River Manor Review score: 6

“The rooms were clean and comfortable. The staff especially Linda were very kind and helpful. Great location getting into Manhattan”
Sag Harbor Inn Review score: 7

“Good location in Sag Harbor. Bed was comfortable and room was big.”
Hampton Inn & Suites Huntington Downtown, Ny Review score: 10

“Great location in a beautiful town. This historical building has very big rooms with everything you need.”

There are even more property options for you

B&Bs and inns in Long Island Holiday rentals in Long Island