United States Put-in-Bay Verified Hotel Reviews by Real Guests
Guests' Choice

The 10 best hotels in Put-in-Bay

Based on 2,078 guest reviews

Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel

#1 of 25 hotels in Put-in-Bay

Last review posted: 10 days ago

  • “I have never stayed anywhere else and do not want to.”
  • “Friendly, relaxing and close to everything.”
  • “Wonderful stay, will definitely be back.”
Bodee's Bungalow Adults Only Couples Only Boutique Hotel

#2 of 25 hotels in Put-in-Bay

Last review posted: 9 days ago

  • “Beds were comfortable and place near everything”
  • “Joe was great!”
  • “”
Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

#3 of 25 hotels in Put-in-Bay

Last review posted: 3 days ago

  • “This was a beautiful inn that is a perfect walking distance...”
  • “”
  • “The room was clean and comfortable.”
Chapman House

#4 of 25 hotels in Put-in-Bay

Last review posted: 11 days ago

  • “Loved the whole place - so cute and comfortable.”
  • “”
  • “The place was really cute and about 15 minutes from the downtown and anywhere we wanted to be! They had a dumb waiter wh”
Islander Inn

#5 of 25 hotels in Put-in-Bay

Last review posted: 2 days ago

  • “The location”
  • “Great time”
  • “”
Bird's Nest Resort

#6 of 25 hotels in Put-in-Bay

Last review posted: 24 days ago

  • “”
  • “Mom's Birthday trip”
  • “Fun and relaxing”
Bayshore Resort At Put-In-Bay

#7 of 25 hotels in Put-in-Bay

Last review posted: 2 days ago

  • “Overall; staff was friendly, the balcony view was exceptional, the location was great with walking distance to the downt”
  • “”
  • “Choose somewhere else. Get your moneys worth.”
Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Center

#8 of 25 hotels in Put-in-Bay

Last review posted: 2 days ago

  • “Overall good place!”
  • “Ok but not great stayed in better”
  • “This was alright.”
Island Club Rentals

#9 of 25 hotels in Put-in-Bay

Last review posted: 9 days ago

  • “”
  • “Nice place. Excellent stay. They could put signs up telling people where their cabins are.”
  • “everything was very good”
Aunt Jane's Two

#10 of 25 hotels in Put-in-Bay

Last review posted: 30 days ago

  • “Location, location, location”
  • “Had a great stay. this property is close to everything and large enough for a big group. The check in person was very fr”
  • “Great location for adults only family reunuion”
Guests' Choice shows you the best and most reviewed properties on top. This is based on the most important topics to our guests, like the number of recent reviews, the review score and the expertise of the reviewer.

Recent reviews

Loading...