There wasn’t much I didn’t like about the property other than the coffee service in the morning. The machine was difficult to use. The pods often fell through and if the machine was working properly, it would’ve been good, but it wasn’t and it frustrated many of the visitors there. You gotta give us coffee in the morning. Rooms at the Springhouse hotel, right next-door were less priced and that property more grand. I found 2 bugs in my room that I killed and reported to the front desk.

The location perched on top of the hill overlooking town Harbour and the small farm below was very nice. As long as you’re a walker, you can get around town from this location. My room is a little small even though I knew it was going to be small. It was a little smaller than I expected just navigating around. The bed was a little difficult, but this was the smallest room they offered. Otherwise it’s a very old building and they had a split system AC that cooled and worked wonderful pillows, bedding everything else was great. There was an absolutely amazing restaurant which was unexpected with a great bar and beautiful balcony and patio to dine on.

Stayed in July 2025

Took a while to find the wifi code.

Wonderful location. Great bathroom and comfortable spacious bedrooms

Stayed in May 2025

Room was on the 3rd floor, steep, tight stairways to rm, no TV, rm was small Inn is not close or a quick walk from town, & uphill the whole way

Beautiful location high above water Inn was lovely, with big lawn area, & large porch

Stayed in August 2024

No comfy chair or fridge in room.

The Inn is perched on a beautiful scenic hill with pleasant views of the ocean. farmland and gorgeous flower gardens. The decor is tasteful and comfortable. Room was clean and comfortable. Appears we had a basic room which is functional for sleeping and showering. There are common areas downstairs and outside to sit and relax. Warm & friendly staff. The rośe and cookie upon arrival was nice touch! Thxs will stay again.

Stayed in August 2024

You could not have done anything better.

We liked the room, the grounds were beautiful and the staff were nice.

Stayed in July 2024

Shower didn’t work well , most of water comes out tub faucet ankle height. Doesn’t really fit 6 people, 2 single blow up mattresses for over 4 people, only 4 people seating in Living and on porch, only kitchen counter seats 6. Room for a dinning table but no dining table. Not enough plates for serving a family , I suspect people who usually stay don’t use the kitchen to cook, they probably eat out.

Beautiful setting, comfortable beds, clean

Stayed in July 2024

The bathroom doors were lovely (panel doors) that came together to close, but these didn’t quite close all the way.

It has gorgeous sweeping views of the island. Beautiful, clean rooms, with a lovely lobby and bar.

Stayed in June 2024

We were promised a king sized room with an ocean view. I have several confirmation emails about it but was placed in a queen size room with island view

Convenient to get to . Quiet

Stayed in June 2024

uphill

quaintness

Stayed in August 2023

No tv. Stairs to third floor hard on senior citizens. Facilities not always open such as bar only opened at five. For a property that has a restaurant a little disappointing on their hours of service. No breakfast served at all. Coffee offered but only after 8 am. Can’t get if your an early riser!

Quiet serene! Great place if you just want to chill. Food was delicious but only offered lunch on weekends.

Stayed in August 2023

The room was tiny, but we had chosen the least expensive room available. Because we were there pre-season the restaurant was closed and there was no breakfast.

The location is great. The staff is friendly and helpful.

Stayed in June 2023

I originally booked a room in the Atlantic inn for the views and the amenities of the hotel however my booking was moved the night before check in to a building behind that appears to be a bed and breakfast under the same managment. They had an issue that was avoidable in my opinion with the town.

Location is great! There is a bike rental on the property which is very convinient. Plenty of parking spots if you come by car on the ferry. Walking distance to ferry and shops.

Stayed in May 2025

The property canceled our reservation the night before due to failing the fire inspection.

Stayed in May 2025

We loved everything about the Inn, it’s very quaint and everything I thought it was going to be. I’ll be back !

Stayed in August 2024

Ripped me off. Tacked on extra $60 charge for no reason. I would never stay there again and plan to use social media to let others know to avoid it. I booked a room for $554, then was told it was $620 when I arrived. Never again. I told them I was upset.

Leaving

Stayed in August 2024

The host was amazing and got me checked in with ease. The glass of Rose and the softer than soft chocolate chip cookies were chef's kiss amazing! The pics of the Veranda Suite completely undersell it. It's awesome and perfect for a small group of friends or coworkers.

Stayed in June 2024

Sarah and Rick were AMAZING! My boyfriend took me for an over night stay at the Atlantic and he proposed! The staff at the Atlantic Inn made it so beyond special. It is truly a night I will never forget. Thank you Sarah and Rick for being so wonderful and making sure I had the best night of my life!!

Stayed in June 2024

Location Deck chairs on lawn with beautiful serene views Clean comfortable family bedroom

Stayed in May 2024

Water available in the lobby or dining area throughout the day.

The Breakfast was adequate. I am an early riser and like coffee first thing. It was a bit difficult to wait until 8:00 for coffee.

Stayed in May 2024

Was traveling alone and never saw another guest. No one was at the desk after 5 pm and the doors were left open all night. Was given a phone number to call if I had any concerns. I did call the number but never received an answer until the following morning. Despite very few, if any, other guests, they would not give me a room on the second floor without an up charge. If you are an older guest, there is no elevator. Lugging suitcases up or down a couple of flights of steep stairs may be challenging.

Stayed in October 2023

Nothing

Quaint and beautifully done

Stayed in August 2023

We wish we had more time to spend and enjoy the restaurant again and beautiful front porch and lawn!!

We can not say enough about the courteous hospitality and amazing attention from Sara and Doug. Our stay was less than 24 hours yet they made us feel like we were life long guests. We cannot thank you enough. Patty and Pat

Stayed in August 2023

My room was the size of a pin and there was nowhere to sit. Had to use the toilet seat to sit on for a seat. The window shade didn't cover the window where the toilet was but did where the window looked at the roof. I was told on booking that I would have a garden view. The view was of the back parking lot and main view the roof. As this was a special event, it was really disappointing as I booked this room well in advance to get a decent room. We couldn't even get in bed from both sides had to crawl over bed to get to the other side. There was no place to put your phone or glass by that side of the bed as well. We felt we really over paid and didn't get much empathy when I asked if we could move the room. Also, it is worth noting that the stairs are quite steep and really worth mentioning on booking or in description as we are older and while we got used to it, other people may not.

I liked the clientele that stayed here and the outdoor porch and lawn chairs. That made our stay and thank god as you couldnt stay in the room it was so small.

Stayed in July 2023

Great location close to town, friendly staff, and small yet comfortable and well-appointed rooms. We especially loved cocktails on the front lawn every day - and the food in the restaurant was delicious!

Stayed in July 2023