Reviews of Captain Whidbey 3 stars

Location and Renovated Historic Facilities. The common lounges, bar and restaurant.

The grounds around some of the annex buildings had construction materials and / or storage materials left out in an untidy manner, which made an aspect of the grounds seem messy.

Bed was comfortable, and staff are very nice and helpful.

Lodge room is so poorly lit that we needed our headlamps for everything except brushing teeth. Lodge room is so very tiny for two people. Must move sideways on far side of bed and to get around the sink. Only one side of bed has a night stand; if that were only issue, we wouldn’t mention it. Drom outside the room, the doorknob does not turn enough that the door can be closed quietly; it should work as well as it does from inside the room. I assume staff have noticed this. This means tha, during the night, when one person goes to use the bathroom, the noise wakes the other person. Finally, the tasting menu was uneven. Some dishes were worthy; others were disappointing.

The location and setting was amazing. The staff were super helpful and very accommodating. The onsite restaurant was delicious and had lots of vegetarian options for us. The yoga room was a nice amenity.

I wish there was an outdoor ahower next to the sauna.

Beautiful, awesome.

Very relaxing and scenic. We had a great dinner in the restaurant. The coffee bar was also very good.

Shower was dimly lit. The weather was exceptionally warm, a ceiling fan would have been nice. The walls were thin. Earplugs should be recommended.

Unique accommodations. Beautiful location. Lots of things to do on site.

The property is very pretty and felt like summer camp

The road noise, the paper thin walls, the extremely hard-as-rock bed, the super squeaky wooden decking so you felt like you’d wake all the other people if you left early, the unprofessionalism of the front desk staff. The guy was eating pizza as he checked us in.

View nice-appreciated the lobby being open 24/7 since the room had no indoor seating options-only beds. Liked the nice porch chairs and all th outdoor seating options in both areas-lagoon and Penn Cove. I really liked the in room coffee option of pour over, vs having those annoying pod machines. Real half n half was also a nice touch.

For the price paid-the bathroom tiled/grout were in need of repair. The bathroom/shower room just needed a little sprucing up. Had to ask for cream and there were no napkins out with the coffee service

From the moment that you pull up to this location and enter through the very beautiful unique entrance, you know that the stay is going to be special. The grounds around the hotel are spectacular as well as the amenities. Being able to sit by a fire pit and watch the sun go down over the water was an incredible moment to have as was being able to get coffee and sit in the sauna the next day.

The food in the restaurant was fantastic as were the drinks. However, some of the staff were not the friendliest, and there was a lot of confusion about who can eat at the restaurant and who could not that kind of ruined the vibe of having dinner there on location.

Fun, wonderful location, great staff.

The first night was a nightmare. A guest had a breakdown of some sort and we could not sleep as all the racket was outside our room. There were two sheriffs and three medics talking loudly in the middle of the night. Unfortunately, the receptionist was not interested in discussing the incident because she may have to offer a discount. Second night was loud to begin with since it was raining, the guests were gathered in the reception area directly below our room. It slowly quieted down and we were able to get some rest.

The room and the lagoon setting were marvelous.

Wait service at the restaurant seemed puzzled by simple issues and requests - and the flow of service seemed haphazard, with a 30 minute wait for the appetizer, which the server hadn't seemed to be aware of. A notice that one of our party was a pescatarian resulted in a dish served with pork belly.

Very nice log cabin. Rustic but nice.

Soooo much charm and the ppl who work there outstanding!. Restaurant was yummy

Little on the pricey side and can here neighbors, but this would not prevent me from coming back

So relaxing and beautiful in nature