Skip to main content
  1. Hotel reviews homepage
  2. USA hotel reviews
  3. South Dakota hotel reviews
  4. Custer hotel reviews
  5. Reviews of Comanche Lodge

Reviews of Comanche Lodge

11915 Buck Lane, Custer, SD 57730, United States

#32 of 34 hotels in Custer

Guests' Choice

Review score

Based on 5 hotel reviews

7.2

Score breakdown

  • Cleanliness

    8.0

  • Comfort

    8.0

  • Location

    9.5

  • Facilities

    8.5

  • Staff

    6.2

  • Value for money

    8.0

100% verified reviews

Real guests. Real stays. Real opinions.

Read more- opens a dialog box
Write a review

Showing 1 – 5

  • Reviewed: 16 June 2023

    8.0
    Extended Family side x side trip
    • Leisure trip
    • Family with young children
    • Five-Bedroom House
    • Stayed 5 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    The house was comfortable and remote, perfect for an extended family side x side trip. Close enough to Custer for daily trips to town for gas, yet quiet and within minutes to the trails.. Ten adults ate and slept comfortably. Parking was available for two cars, three trucks & trailers as well as four side x sides. Excellent communication with hosts.

    Stayed in June 2023

  • Reviewed: 5 August 2024

    4.0
    I would never recommend this place for anyone
    • Leisure trip
    • Family with young children
    • Five-Bedroom House
    • Stayed 3 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    John and Patricia texted us the first night that our kids were being too noisy and we were all in bed. The second night they approached our cabin at 10 o’clock, very aggressively and we’re yelling and screaming to find out they were both intoxicated ended up scaring the kids to where they wanted to go home and to find out it was a house that was water but why would you approach a cabin rental? That way is beyond me?

    Property was in a great location. It was clean and had plenty of room

    Stayed in July 2024

  • Reviewed: 12 July 2024

    10
    Exceptional
    • Leisure trip
    • Group
    • Five-Bedroom House
    • Stayed 4 nights

    wifi is not available

    location

    Stayed in July 2024

  • Reviewed: 21 September 2022

    4.0
    Disappointing
    • Leisure trip
    • Solo traveller
    • Five-Bedroom House
    • Stayed 6 nights

    Upon arrival, there were about 50 moths flying around the cabin. I single-handedly killed over 30 with a fly swatter the first night. This made many of our guests uncomfortable as moths were found under pillows, in the water tank of the coffee maker, etc. The lodge was not as clean and well maintained as we had hoped based on reviews. There was black mold growing around the bathtub and water leaking from the toilet bowl in the bathroom. In addition, the lodge had an unpleasant odor that kind of smelled like mildew or body odor. Our interactions with the hosts were disappointing. We had the feeling of being scrupulously watched and monitored during our stay, almost like having "helicopter hosts". Unfortunately we did not feel treated as valued guests, but rather with suspicion.

    The property was in a good location, surrounded by trees and about 10 minutes from Custer. Not having Wifi or cell phone reception was a positive, as it gave us some time to "unplug" and focus on spending time together.

    Stayed in July 2022

Showing 1 – 5

We Price Match
We Price Match
Low rates • No booking fees • Find cheaper? We'll refund the difference!

Guests also reviewed these properties: