Skip to main content
  1. Hotel reviews homepage
  2. USA hotel reviews
  3. New York State hotel reviews
  4. Montauk hotel reviews
  5. Reviews of Montauk Manor

Reviews of Montauk Manor This rating is a reflection of how the property compares to the industry standard when it comes to price, facilities and services available. It's based on a self-evaluation by the property. Use this rating to help choose your stay!

236 Edgemere Street, Montauk, NY 11954, United States of America

#5 of 27 hotels in Montauk

Guests' Choice

Review Score

Based on 1606 hotel reviews

8.7

Score breakdown

  • Cleanliness

    9.0

  • Comfort

    9.0

  • Location

    9.1

  • Facilities

    8.7

  • Staff

    8.8

  • Value for money

    8.3

  • Free Wifi

    9.0

Verified guest reviews from real Bookers

Real Bookers. Real stays. Real opinions.

Read more– opens a dialog box
Write a Review

Showing 1 - 25

  • Reviewed: May 22, 2024

    10
    Excellent, apart from the food,
    • Leisure trip
    • Solo traveler
    • Executive Studio
    • Stayed 3 nights
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    The quality and variety of the food in the restaurant was very poor, and very expensive. One of our party was violently sick after the calamari, and I got a shrimp dish that was inedible, the “ sauce” had a gravelly texture. The wine was very expensive by the glass, when we realized this and asked to be charged retrospectively by the bottle, our request was rejected.

    The hotel was beautiful, the room was clean, comfortable, and elegantly decorated. The provision of a coach to take us to and from various sites was a great bonus,

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 22, 2024

    10
    Exceptional
    • Leisure trip
    • Group
    • Executive Studio
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    Missing breakfast possibility Restsurant is only open 3 or 4 days a week Bar only open when restaurant is open . That’s the only little remarks , all the rest is great

    Everything is fine, well maintained , staff is helpfull

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 22, 2024

    10
    Exceptional
    • Leisure trip
    • Solo traveler
    • Executive Studio
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    I should have been notified that the restaurant would be closed on Tuesday, especially during check in time. Also it would be nice if you could provide us a pen in our room.

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 22, 2024

    10
    I can’t wait to go back !!!
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe Studio
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    NOTHING

    EVERYTHING

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 21, 2024

    8.0
    Very nice hotel and area
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Executive Studio
    • Stayed 2 nights

    beds were very old and worn out

    balcony

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 20, 2024

    9.0
    Wonderful
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe Studio
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    Lobby bar was very small. Need coffe service set up in lobby. Does not have to be complimentary but it really would have made my stay perfect. Resented having to get dressed and drive to town to look for coffee.

    Everything.

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 20, 2024

    10
    The CASTLE IN AMERICA that you can stay at and enjoy all the amenities!
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Superior Deluxe Suite With Fireplace
    • Stayed 3 nights
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    Nothing

    The Manor is just MAGNIFICENT!

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 19, 2024

    8.0
    Relaxing peaceful 40th anniversary stay for us. MC
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Executive Studio
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    Wish MM played piped in music in the gorgeous lobby or had entertainment of some kind like a piano player, etc.

    Beds were fine, pillows too soft, we loved the room, the grounds, We loved Montes restaurant, wished it was open during our full stay there.. all in all, we'll be back. Loved MM.

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 17, 2024

    9.0
    Wonderful
    • Leisure trip
    • Solo traveler
    • Loft Suite
    • Stayed 4 nights
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    The staffs at the front desk could be more friendly.

    Beautiful architecture, the water view, close to the center of the town and the train station.

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 14, 2024

    10
    Exceptional
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Executive Studio
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    No complaints

    Everything was just great.

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 14, 2024

    9.0
    Wonderful
    • Leisure trip
    • Group
    • Three-Bedroom Suite
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    The WiFi didn’t work

    The three bedroom condo was beautiful

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 13, 2024

    8.0
    Grand dame of Montauk, imperfect but very nice
    • Leisure trip
    • Family with young children
    • Deluxe Loft Suite
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    The interiors are somewhat dates and my room (137) was a duplex that must have been converted from double height. The upper room had no windows so that was weird. No beach access.

    Beautiful old school hotel. Grand medieval style lobby. My room had amazing view of the sound. But it was large and would sleep 6 including a pull out couch.

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 12, 2024

    10
    Very relaxing and quiet!
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Executive Studio
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    There’s nothing negative I could say about the property.

    Beautiful surroundings, nice restaurant and the shuttle service they provide to locations in Montauk.

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 9, 2024

    9.0
    An amazing place and kept in exceptional conditions
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe Loft Suite
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    Nothing at all

    Spotless, panoramic and beautiful

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 8, 2024

    8.0
    Very Good
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe Suite
    • Stayed 5 nights

    Neither pool was open which was disappointing. We would love to have had breakfast on weekdays as well.

    The Room was lovely with a magnificent view. Breakfast on Saturday and Sunday was delicious. A car kindly took us to the Jitney stop Will definitely stay again.

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 8, 2024

    8.0
    Overall, it was a really good stay. Love the scenery outside and the room with the cool pictures!
    • Leisure trip
    • Group
    • Deluxe Suite
    • Stayed 2 nights

    Elevator was too slow. Sofa bed was uncomfortable. Didn't have a cooking pan in oven.

    Very nice room. Had grill outside to cook food. Had a great view/scenery outside as well.

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 6, 2024

    10
    My daughter and I love the property. The grounds are immaculate! The staff is amazing. The restaurant was fantastic!! A
    • Leisure trip
    • Family with young children
    • Deluxe Suite
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    Nothing !

    ABSOLUTELY EVERYTHING!! My daughter and I come every year for a pre Mother’s Day celebration!!

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 6, 2024

    10
    Charming old world class.
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe Loft Suite
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    Love the isolated location and the turn of the century feel. Very classy.

    Stayed in May 2024

  • Reviewed: May 1, 2024

    10
    A great peaceful way to enjoy a weekend away.
    • Leisure trip
    • Group
    • Deluxe Loft Suite
    • Stayed 3 nights
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    The bed that I stayed in was really firm, and hard to fall asleep in.

    Monte’s restaurant was great

    Stayed in April 2024

  • Reviewed: May 1, 2024

    10
    Relaxing and enjoyable.
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Executive Studio
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    Beautiful grounds, close to shopping. Friendly and accommodating staff and lovely room.

    Stayed in April 2024

  • Reviewed: April 26, 2024

    9.0
    Wonderful
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe Studio
    • Stayed 3 nights
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    Stunning views Comfortable and spacious room Shuttle service to take you anywhere in the area and pick you up from wherever was extremely useful

    Stayed in April 2024

  • Reviewed: April 25, 2024

    8.0
    Very Good
    • Leisure trip
    • Family with young children
    • Loft Suite
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    The bed in rm 109 has to be replaced.

    Stayed in April 2024

  • Reviewed: April 25, 2024

    8.0
    Very Good
    • Leisure trip
    • Family with young children
    • Deluxe Suite
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    The bed in rm 109 was absolutely horrible. We stay here all the time in all different rooms, for years and years. The room was impeccable, but the bed has to go. We were only staying one night this time, but we would of had to move rooms if it was more.

    We love this place

    Stayed in April 2024

  • Reviewed: April 25, 2024

    10
    Relaxing
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Executive Studio
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted from a mobile device

    The lower parking lot is a hike

    Always clean comfortable convenient

    Stayed in April 2024

Showing 1 - 25

We Price Match
We Price Match
Low rates • No booking fees • Find something cheaper? We'll refund the difference!

Guests also reviewed these properties: