The grounds were beautifully kept and the hotel was quaint

Stayed in June 2025

Nothing

Comfy bed and great sheets!

Stayed in June 2025

Lobby had a strong odor of fireplace.

Staff were so pleasant.

Stayed in May 2025

Nothing

Clean comfortable and great service. Food was excellent rooms were clean great location.

Stayed in January 2025

The first room we were given didn't have heat. When we notified the front desk later in the evening, they provided us with a space heater. It wasn't until the following morning when we again spoke with the front desk that we were provided with a different room that thankfully this time was heated.

The inn is beautiful and I enjoyed breakfast. It was fun playing scrabble by the fire with a drink!

Stayed in December 2024

The dining room was a little cold but still enjoyable

The atmosphere was nostalgic and the facility was clean Everyone was extremely nice

Stayed in December 2024

I can’t think of anything that was negative.

The look of the Inn, location, friendly staff, the fresh food, hot breakfast each morning, the bar with wine tasting & the amazing cheese cake. Also the fireplace was magnificent.

Stayed in November 2024

There was no land line in the room. And no clock in the room.

Really enjoyed our stay at The Settlers Inn. The room was very spacious. Staff was very friendly. The breakfasts were delicious!

Stayed in October 2024

I have reviewed the beds here before. The mattress is on a wooden frame which sticks out past the edge of the mattress. My husband and I have both not seen the frame in the dark and hit our calves on it. His drew blood. Fortunatly it was not much but it hurt alot. We don't understand why they don't make the frame disappear under the mattress. I end up putting pillows and furniture near the end of the bed as a reminder.

This was the third time we have stayed at Old Settlers Inn. There is so much to like here. The food is excellent, sourced from a local farm. Antiques are charming. The staff are all extremely helpful and kind.

Stayed in October 2024

Mattress was too soft and the lights shined through the window

Stayed in October 2024

Nothing everything was great.

The place is so relaxing. The garden is so pretty. And the food is so dang good.

Stayed in September 2024

The bathroom door really squeaked when you open and closed it. It's not a deal breaker and an easy fix.

Laid back old school atmosphere.

Stayed in August 2024

The frame of the bed stuck out to the point where I impaled my leg on it. The mattress is much smaller and the wood frame pieces are not protected. They are very dangerous, especially navigating them in the dark of night. Also the lack of an elevator was a potential problem for me. I did not see in the description of the hotel that it is impossible for anyone with mobility problems. One has to be able to climb stairs.

Carrie at the desk was very helpful. We asked lots of questions....questions she no doubt answers numerous times a day...and she was patient. We loved eating on the porch and the attention paid to us by our waitress. The gardens and creative and welcoming.

Stayed in August 2024

Lobby smelled a little like smoke

Beautiful gardens and outdoor areas. The staff were extremely attentive and provided excellent service. The access to activities across all the sister properties

Stayed in August 2024

There were drifty cobwebs on the ceiling of my room that are common in old buildings. The shower drain was slow. I reported these concerns so hopefully it won't be an issue for the next guest. There is no elevator! Buyer beware. I could hear footfalls of the resident above me, but it didn't ruin my trip. The wifi is not secure, so I didn't bother to use it.

The included breakfast was made to order which was delightful. (I tire of reconstituted eggs at the big chains.) The staff was very gracious and helpful and accomodating. Zero complaints there. My room was spacious, though I know others are smaller. They're not all cut the same. I was grateful for the AC split in my room.

Stayed in June 2024

We would have loved a lift to get to the first floor as our case was heavy to get up the stairs, but it's a historic building so we totally understand why there isn't one! (next time we will pack less!) So really we liked absolutely everything. All was good.

Loved it! Fabulous staff, friendly, enthusiastic and helpful. Gorgeous reception and bar area, even Scrabble and Chess boards laid out. We didn't walk around the gardens due to lack of time, but they looked stunning from the terrace. Lots of little things to love about The Settlers Inn. Breakfast was super too.

Stayed in June 2024

nothing

Breakfast just excellent, also we were seated outside for dinner

Stayed in June 2024

A favorite for dinner whenever we are in town, and our first stay for a night was wonderful. Such a beautiful setting and the restoration of the entire property is inspiring.

Stayed in May 2024

NA

Beautiful period property. Lovely Craftsman design. We got to see the sister hotels which were also great. We followed the waterfall tour recommended by the hotel. It was awesome. Would not have known about it otherwise. The dinner and breakfast at Settlers inn was top notch. Great wine list.

Stayed in May 2024

For our group the steps were a problem.. We had hoped this wouldn’t be a big problem but it was. The rooms were a bit small but the bed was nice and firm.

The grounds are very pretty and the inn is lovely. The food was delicious as well.

Stayed in May 2024

The restaurant menu was somewhat limited and they probably need a new chef. Too much fried food.

Restful atmosphere, good accommodations

Stayed in April 2024

no local tv stations

Food and ambiance excellent

Stayed in April 2024

The welcoming warmness of the Manger and everyone on staff made us feel special from the moment we stepped into the impressive great room and hospitality desk. The room amenities such as the mattress, pillows, etc were extremely comfortable, clean and well appointed. The breakfast was included and we had a choice of anything on the menu! There were also activities such as yoga that we could participate in. So.. when factored in... was a good value. Totally relaxing. I love the craftsman antiques, huge fireplace, beautiful bar and grounds. I would stay again!

Stayed in March 2024

Our bed was a little hard for our liking but otherwise no complaints at all!

The breakfast and all our meals were exceptional! We didn't leave the Inn once. The service is wonderful, attention to every detail. The bar is cozy and hospitable, you just feel welcomed in every way!

Stayed in January 2024