Tarpon Tale Inn is a fabulous stay! My boyfriend and I spent a short weekend here, and it was above and beyond our expectations. The room was so clean and quaint, and the location could not be in a more perfect spot! It was literally a 5 minute walk to the beach! They had sweet little amenities such as a small fire pit area, a hammock for lounging, each room has a small outdoor patio perfect for breakfast or dinner! Not to mention they provided us with beach towels, shelling gear, even beach chairs! I can’t imagine staying anywhere else on Sanibel now, especially for the value!! You simply cannot beat Tarpon Tale Inn!

Stayed in August 2025

Nothing

Price and location

Stayed in August 2025

Loved everything!

Everything! Location, friendly staff, and the extras like bikes, beach towels and beach chairs.

Stayed in August 2025

From the moment we arrived, Tarpon Tale Inn felt like a little island home. Our room was spotless, cozy, and had everything we needed for a relaxing stay. The location is perfect —close to the beach, yet tucked away enough to enjoy peace and quiet. The extra touches like bikes, beach gear, and the outdoor shower made it so easy to explore Sanibel without stress. Joe and the team were always kind, helpful, and quick to respond to any questions, even if we didn’t see them often in person. It’s clear they put their heart into this place, and it shows in every detail. We’re grateful for the warm hospitality and would absolutely stay here again. Highly recommended for anyone looking to experience the true charm of Sanibel Island. 💛🌴

Stayed in August 2025

Joe and Son were great.

Stayed in July 2025

Nothing.

Location. Staff. Amenities.

Stayed in July 2025

Thank you so much for the opportunity to enjoy your wonderful hospitality! The location is fantastic, the place is fully equipped with everything we needed, and we loved the free access to bicycles. Joe, the owner, was incredibly helpful and kind, which made our stay even more enjoyable. We truly had a great time and highly recommend this place to everyone!

Stayed in June 2025

Nothing

Absolutely perfect for a getaway on Sanibel Island. They provided bikes and beach gear. Short walk to the beach. Restaurant and shops very close by. Reasonable rates for such a great destination.

Stayed in June 2025

The staff and owner were incredible— genuine, helpful, and accommodating. They really have everything you need for a fantastic leisurely beach experience. It is evident how much they care about making sure guests are taken care of. Bikes, beach carts, shelling tools, bug spray (beware of the No See Ums), umbrellas, etc. Located in the midst of cute little restaurants and a short walk to Lighthouse Beach. Clean and updated suites. Highly recommend!

Stayed in May 2025

Very close to so many things.

Stayed in May 2025

That we had to go home!

This is an amazing hidden gem. Maybe the best vacation experience ever. The extra details that they put into making your stay over the top made us feel special. Already booked again. They cared so much about our stay and we were so appreciative!!!!

Stayed in May 2025

Pleasantly surprised at proximity to the Beach. Great helpful staff

Stayed in April 2025

Clean, included bikes and beach equipment. Close to restaurants and beach.

Stayed in March 2025

What breakfast? Location was great, loved the extra effort and details. It was a quick trip for my daughter and me, and we were moved here from a different location because the other one was overbooked It was a great find

Stayed in March 2025

It wasn't ocean front.

Although it was not oceanfront it had a very quaint courtyard to sit in that was extremely relaxing. Right across the street was an awesome restaurant, yogurt shop, shopping. Definitely worth the trip.

Stayed in February 2025

The property is well kept and well appointed.

Stayed in February 2025

Nothing. It was perfect

Fantastic stay! Could not ask for more. Bikes, chairs, umbrella, even a wagon to take to the beach. Owner showed us around, answered our questions, and was very responsive when we needed anything. Would stay again in a heartbeat.

Stayed in January 2025

It was very buggy in the back garden. We got eaten alive.

The location was great. Owner is wonderful. The caretaker is nice and helpful. Had bikes available to use. Lovely gardens to sit out front or on our little deck. Quick walk to beach with chairs and towels available.

Stayed in January 2025

Bathroom steps are dangerous

Really great people , do be careful in steps to bathroom I suggest you put in a night light that comes on when you get close to steps

Stayed in September 2024

Awesome

Stayed in September 2024

Love the property, our room was spotless and comfortable. The owner is very professional, helpful and strives to accommodate guest.

Stayed in August 2024

Nothing it was awesome

Beautiful and had everything you can think of you might need at the beach, but you didn’t need to bring it, they had it!

Stayed in July 2024

Absolutely everything. Me and my wife decided to change up an old tradition and start a new one for our anniversary. 19 years together. We thought we were going to spend a couple of years trying to find a new one. Nope, Tarpon Tale Inn delivered exceptionally well. If you are looking for a quiet get away with amenities that will blow your mind look no further. Parking right beside the beach, bikes for your leisure, beach wagon and other beach goodies to take on your journey,outdoor showers so you can rinse off before going in your room, a sea shell washing bench to go through all your shells and clean them before sticking them back in your car for a long trip home. I honestly feel blessed I ran across this gem. It is ran by Father and Son, Joe and Connor. It did my heart well to support such an establishment! Thank you Joe and Connor. See you next Sept 1st!

Stayed in September 2024

Very clean, love the owner. He has a tremendous amount of pride and compassion for the Inn. Across the street nice shop to get coffee and a place to eat. Great air conditioning.

Stayed in August 2024