Reviews of The Menhaden Hotel 4 stars
207 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

Loading
Guests also reviewed these properties:
How guest reviews work
Each review score is between 1-10. To get the overall score that you see, we add up all the review scores we’ve received and divide that total by the number of review scores we’ve received. We use a weighted review system which means that the more recent the review, the bigger the impact on the total review score calculation. In addition, guests can give separate ‘subscores’ in crucial areas, such as location, cleanliness, staff, comfort, facilities, value for money and free Wi-Fi. Note that guests submit their subscores and their overall scores independently, so there’s no direct link between them.
You can review an Accommodation that you booked through our Platform if you stayed there or if you arrived at the property but didn’t actually stay there. To edit a review you’ve already submitted, please contact our Customer Service team.
We have people and automated systems that specialise in detecting fake reviews submitted to our Platform. If we find any, we delete them and, if necessary, take action against whoever is responsible.
Anyone else who spots something suspicious can always report it to our Customer Service team, so our Fraud team can investigate.
Ideally, we would publish every review we receive, whether positive or negative. However, we won’t display any review that includes or refers to (among other things):
- Politically sensitive comments
- Promotional content
- Illegal activities
- Personal or sensitive information (e.g. emails, phone numbers or credit card info)
- Swear words, sexual references, hate speech, discriminatory remarks, threats, or references to violence
- Spam and fake content
- Animal cruelty
- Impersonation (e.g. if the writer is claiming to be someone else)
- Any violation of our review guidelines.
To make sure reviews are relevant, we may only accept reviews that are submitted within 3 months of checking out, and we may stop showing reviews once they’re 36 months old – or if the Accommodation has a change of ownership.
An Accommodation may choose to reply to a review.
When you see multiple reviews, the most recent ones will be at the top, subject to a few other factors (what language a review is in, whether it’s just a rating or contains comments as well, etc.). If you like, you can sort and/or filter them (by time of year, review score, etc.).
We sometimes show external review scores from other well-known travel websites. We make it clear when we’ve done this.
Guidelines and standards for Reviews
These guidelines and standards aim to keep the content on Booking.com relevant and family-friendly without limiting expression of strong opinions. They are also applicable regardless of the sentiment of the comment.
Contributions should be travel related. The most helpful contributions are detailed and help others make better decisions. Please don’t include personal, political, ethical, or religious commentary. Promotional content will be removed and issues concerning Booking.com’s services should be routed to our Customer Service or Accommodation Service teams.
Contributions should be appropriate for a global audience. Please avoid using profanity or attempts to approximate profanity with creative spelling, in any language. Comments and media that include 'hate speech', discriminatory remarks, threats, sexually explicit remarks, violence, and the promotion of illegal activity are not permitted.
All content should be genuine and unique to the guest. Reviews are most valuable when they are original and unbiased. Your contribution should be yours. Booking.com property partners should not post on behalf of guests or offer incentives in exchange for reviews. Attempts to bring down the rating of a competitor by submitting a negative review will not be tolerated.
Respect the privacy of others. Booking.com will make an effort to obscure email addresses, telephone numbers, website addresses, social media accounts, and similar details.
The opinions expressed in contributions are those of Booking.com customers and properties and not of Booking.com. Booking.com does not accept responsibility or liability for any reviews or responses. Booking.com is a distributor (without any obligation to verify) and not a publisher of these comments and responses.
By default, reviews are sorted based on the date of the review and on additional criteria to display the most relevant reviews, including but not limited to: your language, reviews with text, and non-anonymous reviews. Additional sorting options may be available (by type of traveller, by score, etc.).
Translations disclaimer
This service may contain translations powered by Google. Google disclaims all warranties related to the translations, express or implied, including any warranties of accuracy, reliability, and any implied warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose and non-infringement.
Reviewed: 7 August 2025 · Stayed in August 2025
Verified reviewReviewed: 29 July 2025 · Stayed in July 2025
Verified reviewThe attention to detail was extraordinary and the little extras, like interesting snacks, showed a real caring for the guests.
Reviewed: 21 July 2025 · Stayed in July 2025
Verified reviewReviewed: 24 May 2025 · Stayed in May 2025
Verified reviewBreakfast was fresh and delicious. Staff did a lot of personal touches. Was an amazing experience! I can’t wait to go back again!
Thank you for choosing The Menhaden for your stay! We are thrilled to hear that you enjoyed our fresh and delicious breakfast and appreciated our personalized service. Your kind words mean a lot to us, and we can't wait to welcome you back for another amazing experience. Safe travels until we see you again!
Thank you for choosing The Menhaden for your stay! We are thrilled to hear that you enjoyed our fresh and delicious breakfast and appreciated our personalized service. Your kind words mean a lot to us, and we can't wait to welcome you back … Show more
Reviewed: 17 April 2025 · Stayed in April 2025
Verified reviewReviewed: 15 April 2025 · Stayed in April 2025
Verified reviewReviewed: 1 April 2025 · Stayed in March 2025
Verified reviewReviewed: 29 March 2025 · Stayed in March 2025
Verified reviewReviewed: 19 March 2025 · Stayed in March 2025
Verified reviewReviewed: 20 February 2025 · Stayed in February 2025
Verified reviewReviewed: 20 February 2025 · Stayed in December 2024
Verified reviewReviewed: 17 February 2025 · Stayed in February 2025
Verified reviewThe heating system was Not working properly and the room was uncomfortably cold . . .
Dear Francis X, Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We're truly sorry to hear that the heating system in your room wasn't functioning properly, resulting in an uncomfortably cold stay. We understand how important a comfortable room temperature is, especially during colder periods. We're addressing the heating issue immediately to ensure it's resolved for future guests. We appreciate you bringing this to our attention, as it helps us improve our services. We hope you'll consider staying with us again, and we'll do our best to provide you with a much more comfortable experience. Warm regards, The Menhaden Hotel Team
Dear Francis X, Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We're truly sorry to hear that the heating system in your room wasn't functioning properly, resulting in an uncomfortably cold stay. We understand how important … Show more
Reviewed: 13 February 2025 · Stayed in February 2025
Verified reviewThe location is ideal
I like to be able to control the thermostat in the room and I was not able to do that and it was cold
Dear Sean, Thank you so much for your glowing ratings across the board! We're thrilled to hear you found our location ideal and enjoyed your overnight escape. We appreciate your feedback regarding the thermostat. We understand how important it is to have control over your room's temperature and we sincerely apologize that you were unable to adjust it and that your room was cold. We are currently investigating the thermostat controls in our rooms to ensure they are functioning correctly and easily accessible for our guests. We're glad to hear that everything else met your expectations, and we hope to have the opportunity to welcome you back for another stay, where we can ensure you have full control of your room's comfort. Warm regards, The Menhaden Hotel Team
Dear Sean, Thank you so much for your glowing ratings across the board! We're thrilled to hear you found our location ideal and enjoyed your overnight escape. We appreciate your feedback regarding the thermostat. We understand how imp… Show more
Reviewed: 28 January 2025 · Stayed in January 2025
Verified reviewReviewed: 26 December 2024 · Stayed in December 2024
Verified reviewReviewed: 20 December 2024 · Stayed in December 2024
Verified reviewReviewed: 10 December 2024 · Stayed in December 2024
Verified reviewThe hotel is continently located and spotless. The staff is warm, welcoming, and attentive. They offered the little extras that made our stay perfect!
Nothing
Dear Deseriee, Wow! Thank you so much for your absolutely wonderful review and perfect 10 ratings! We are thrilled to hear you found our hotel conveniently located and spotless. It's especially rewarding to know that our staff's warm, welcoming, and attentive service made your stay perfect, and that you appreciated the little extras we strive to provide. We truly value your kind words. We hope to have the pleasure of welcoming you back to The Menhaden Hotel for another exceptional stay in the future.
Dear Deseriee, Wow! Thank you so much for your absolutely wonderful review and perfect 10 ratings! We are thrilled to hear you found our hotel conveniently located and spotless. It's especially rewarding to know that our staff's w… Show more
Reviewed: 5 December 2024 · Stayed in December 2024
Verified reviewIt was in the town , the kitchen and treats on every floor were great
The breakfast is not really a breakfast more just coffee which is available all day and a few danishes. There was no fruit and they ran out of the plan yogurt. I just would not advertise as breakfast included and then what you have would seem great.
Dear Barbara, Thank you for sharing your feedback and for your overall 8.0 rating. We're delighted to hear you enjoyed your winter weekend with us, particularly the convenient location, the kitchen, and the treats on each floor! We truly appreciate your honest comments regarding our breakfast offering. We understand your point about it not fully meeting the expectations of a traditional breakfast. We are taking your feedback seriously and will be reviewing how we present and enhance our breakfast options. Your suggestion to adjust our advertising to accurately reflect the offering is well-received. We aim to provide transparency and ensure our guests are fully informed. We will be looking into providing a wider variety of items like fruit and ensuring we are stocked with items like yogurt. Thank you again for your valuable input. We hope to have the opportunity to welcome you back and provide an even more satisfying experience.
Dear Barbara, Thank you for sharing your feedback and for your overall 8.0 rating. We're delighted to hear you enjoyed your winter weekend with us, particularly the convenient location, the kitchen, and the treats on each floor! We tr… Show more
Reviewed: 4 December 2024 · Stayed in December 2024
Verified reviewCleanliness, our room was spotless; the fully stocked galley; freshly baked chocolate chip cookies each night.
Dear Harvey, Thank you for your fantastic 10/10 review! We are absolutely delighted to hear you had a wonderful stay at The Menhaden Hotel. We're thrilled that you found our cleanliness to be exceptional and your room spotless. It's also wonderful to know you enjoyed our fully stocked galley and the freshly baked chocolate chip cookies each night – those are some of our favorite touches too! And thank you for the wonderful bed rating of 10! We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience and hope to welcome you back for another exceptional stay soon. Warm regards, The Menhaden Hotel Team
Dear Harvey, Thank you for your fantastic 10/10 review! We are absolutely delighted to hear you had a wonderful stay at The Menhaden Hotel. We're thrilled that you found our cleanliness to be exceptional and your room spotless. It… Show more
Reviewed: 21 November 2024 · Stayed in November 2024
Verified reviewWe loved the offerings in the galley especially the cookies at night!
Perhaps a small table in the rooms for the pickings.
Dear Lenore, Thank you for your absolutely perfect 10/10 review! We are so thrilled to hear that you loved your entire experience, from check-in to your departure gift. We're especially happy you enjoyed the offerings in our galley, particularly the late-night cookies! It's wonderful to know those little touches made your stay memorable. We also appreciate your thoughtful suggestion about adding a small table in the rooms for enjoying the galley pickings. We'll certainly take this into consideration as we continue to enhance our guest experience. We hope to have the pleasure of welcoming you back to The Menhaden Hotel for another exceptional stay.
Dear Lenore, Thank you for your absolutely perfect 10/10 review! We are so thrilled to hear that you loved your entire experience, from check-in to your departure gift. We're especially happy you enjoyed the offerings in our galle… Show more
Reviewed: 14 October 2024 · Stayed in October 2024
Verified reviewAmazing team working there made us feel very welcome and at home.
Floors were creaky and we could hear the people upstairs walking through the floor.
Dear Patrick, Thank you for your excellent feedback and for your overall 8.0 rating! We're thrilled to hear that our amazing team made you feel very welcome and at home. We sincerely apologize for the noise disturbance caused by the creaky floors and the sound of guests walking above you. We understand that this impacted your comfort, and we are looking into solutions to minimize noise disruptions for future guests. This is something we are taking seriously and are actively looking into solutions. We're delighted that you enjoyed the other aspects of your stay, particularly the staff, cleanliness, location, and facilities. We hope you'll consider staying with us again, and we'll do our best to ensure a more peaceful and comfortable experience.
Dear Patrick, Thank you for your excellent feedback and for your overall 8.0 rating! We're thrilled to hear that our amazing team made you feel very welcome and at home. We sincerely apologize for the noise disturbance caused by the c… Show more
Reviewed: 15 September 2024 · Stayed in August 2024
Verified reviewReviewed: 15 September 2024 · Stayed in July 2024
Verified reviewThe exceptional experience began immediately! We were greeted at the desk with warmth and acknowledged as repeat visitors. All of our requests regarding room location, extra towels and pillows were acknowledged and provided. The rooms are so gorgeous and clean. This notel has beautifully stocked galley kitchens on each floor with water, cookies in the evening, croissant in the am and little nibble to be found all day. The location is perfect and the staff goes out of their way anytime you need them!
Nothing
Dear Christine, Wow! Thank you so much for your absolutely glowing 10/10 review! We are truly honored that The Menhaden Hotel is one of your absolute favorite hotels anywhere! We are thrilled to hear that your exceptional experience began immediately and that you felt welcomed and recognized as a repeat visitor. It's wonderful to know that we were able to fulfill your requests and that you found our rooms gorgeous and clean. We're also delighted you enjoyed our fully stocked galley kitchens and the little touches we provide throughout the day. We are so happy to know you enjoy the location and the staff. Your kind words are incredibly rewarding, and we look forward to welcoming you back for many more exceptional stays. Warm regards, The Menhaden Hotel Team
Dear Christine, Wow! Thank you so much for your absolutely glowing 10/10 review! We are truly honored that The Menhaden Hotel is one of your absolute favorite hotels anywhere! We are thrilled to hear that your exceptional experience b… Show more
Reviewed: 15 September 2024 · Stayed in July 2024
Verified review