Breakfast was always good. Loved the patio setting.

Stayed in August 2025

Great trip.

Entire staff was excellent, made you feel at home and top level VIP attitudes. Breakfast was great each morning hand made by staff and served in a garden area. The location is around 2 blocks from the Duval Loop bus stops and great value to shuttle around the entire downtown area of attractions. The Hemmingway Home and Key West Butterfly Conservatory were both excellent things to see. Sunset at Mallory Square was great and Gladiators Ice Cream Shoppe was excellent. A few restaurants are not open on Mon-Tues so check before walking there. The Lobster Shack on Front Street was excellent for lunch! Also the Dive Bar Shirt Club on Grinnell St totally cool and great Tecos.

Stayed in July 2025

Everything at this place is so beautiful and warm

Stayed in July 2025

Charming , elegant B&B. Great location, very close to Duval Street.

Stayed in July 2025

Steps to the top, but that's the room I chose. No fault to them.

Warm, cozy, comfortable, relaxing. Bed was very inviting.

Stayed in July 2025

End of June 2025 ~ Wonderful weekend in the Keys thanks to the lovely accommodations at the Mermaid & Alligator. Once inside the gates of the property, we were met by a lush patio oasis with a beautifully appointed and clean room that perfectly captured, in stylish fashion, the look & feel of Key West living. A small plunge pool with water temp in 86° range was very nice and allowed one to better appreciate the garden, vegetation, and ambiance. Courtesy pool towels are available poolside. Layout of property minimized contact with other guests and really made one feel you had the property largely to yourself. Glassware provided for drinks, with complimentary soft drinks, water, and snacks. There is a small ice machine available as well. Shampoo, conditioner, and body wash included. No TVs in the room provided a refreshing break from the 24/7 news cycle - and of course, you always have your phone with free wifi included if you can't resist. We had no fridge in the room either, but with the common area fridge stocked with water, soft drinks and the occasional beer, and the communal fridge centrally located; we really didn't need it. Located right off of Truman Ave, closer to the Southernmost point than Sloppy Joe's Bar & Restaurant, the neighborhood is extremely nice and felt very safe. We combined walking and driving to see the town. It was quite warm during our visit, so we drove a bit more than we originally planned, but with parking readily available everywhere we went, and things being so close, there were no issues. Speaking of parking: Parking on the property was limited, but free parking on the street is literally located just feet away and was readily available. A daily breakfast is included, which other guests told us was quite good, but sadly our schedule didn't allow us to enjoy it ourselves. The hostess & small housekeeping staff were very pleasant and inconspicuous unless needed.

Stayed in June 2025

The property is located close to Duval Street, but far enough away to be outwith the hustle and bustle. We had the Caribbean King room and it was beautiful, with a great wrap around balcony. The property is located on the corner of Truman Avenue, which while busy with traffic during the day, is not an issue. The garden area is a bit of a sanctuary and is a lovely spot to have breakfast in the morning. It’s around a 5 minute walk to Duval Street, so very well positioned. Breakfast was excellent, with lots of fresh fruit, coffee and cereal etc. The staff are all excellent and do all they can to make your stay pleasant.

Stayed in May 2025

Breakfast was ok

A piece of history well located in old town key west Very green and convenient You can rent bike a the property

Stayed in April 2025

A lot of thought has gone into the property. We loved all the individual features in our room and the communal areas. It was great to have breakfast included. Everything in walking distance.

Stayed in April 2025

Nothing

The hotel is in a historic building which is tastefully restored - great vibe, but also very comfortable. Location is central but quiet. All the staff is very nice and helpful. One of the best stays overall in a while.

Stayed in April 2025

The price was a little steep, but we didn't realize it was Spring Break. We would absolutely recommend this to our friends and family.

Everything, from the moment we walked into the inn, to the time we left, the staff, location, accommodations, snacks, breakfast, everything was so charming and lovely! Easy location to walk to Duval Street.

Stayed in March 2025

For real! This Place is auch a Paradise!

Stayed in February 2025

Everything was perfect and everybody was so kind and nice. Thank you for our stay.

Stayed in February 2025

Loved the atmosphere and Diana was a friendly representative of the property. Breakfast was amazing.

Stayed in January 2025

Ceilings were very low in our room, but the room was still very nice.

Breakfast was delicious

Stayed in January 2025

Minor detail, but we really didn’t like the ceiling fan. And that it only had one speed. Also be prepared for loud roosters throughout the night, but that is just part of being in Key West.

The room was designed with a lot of love and really gave a cozy island vibe. We felt comfortable from the first second. The breakfast was great. The location super convenient, with enough parking. And the staff was very welcoming and helpful.

Stayed in January 2025

I absolutely loved and appreciated the way all the staff treated us. They were professional but also treated us like family.

Stayed in December 2024

Lovely hotel full of character. The kitchen snacks and wine hour were a great personal touch!

Stayed in November 2024

I liked it all. I have no criticism whatsoever.

It was unique and very homey. The rooms were beautifully decorated. The staff was kind and helpful. Everything about this property with amazing: the comfort, the location and the staff!

Stayed in October 2024

Better ice machine would be good. Breakfast ok could be better, a bit slow on the service.

Location. Beautiful property, cosy, pool

Stayed in October 2024

Breakfast is included. The french toast was delicious but I needed protein. The other monring there were eggs but I am picky about my eggs and I do not like them over cooked. Just my preference.

The location was a little far to walk to Old Town but we were able to find parking everywhere we went. The room we stayed in, Carribbean Queen was lovely, with a large soaking tub and wrap around porch on the second floor. The "pool" is a large hot tub in a lovely garden. The grounds are well kept and relaxing.

Stayed in August 2024

This place has a lot of personality. Our room had a unique design and was fun to stay at. Very good breakfast.

Stayed in June 2024

There was nothing that we didn’t like!

This was the most unique place we have ever stayed! The employees were stellar!

Stayed in July 2024

I don’t have any complaints about property.

Cozy and quiet surrounded by palms and trees.

Stayed in April 2024